Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGIP) — Analyst outlook / Analyst consensus target is. Based on 11 analyst ratings, the consensus is bullish — 3 Buy, 7 Hold, 1 Sell.
Analysts estimate Earnings Per Share (EPS) of $3.63 and revenue of $4.66B for the next fiscal year.
Earnings Per Share (EPS) track record: 2024: actual $3.55 vs est $3.63 (missed -2.3%). 2025: actual $7.48 vs est $6.83 (beat +9.5%). Analyst accuracy: 94%.
SIGIP Analyst Ratings
Hold
Based on 11 analysts giving stock ratings to Selective Insurance Group, Inc. in the past 3 months
EPS Estimates — SIGIP
94%
Analyst Accuracy
Accurate
2 years compared
Actual vs Estimate
2024
Actual $3.55
vs Est $3.63
▼ 2.4% off
2025
Actual $7.48
vs Est $6.83
▲ 8.7% off
Profitability Outlook
Strong profitability with high earnings per share. EPS trend is improving.
Revenue Estimates — SIGIP
94%
Analyst Accuracy
Accurate
2 years compared
Actual vs Estimate
2024
Actual $4.861B
vs Est $4.661B
▲ 4.1% off
2025
Actual $5.337B
vs Est $4.954B
▲ 7.2% off
Revenue Trend
Revenue has been relatively flat. Analysts forecast revenue contraction ahead.
