American Financial Group, Inc. AFG NYSE

NYSE • Financial Services • Insurance - Property & Casualty • US • USD

SharesGrow Score

67/100

3/7 Pass

SharesGrow Intrinsic Value

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) has 20 known insider and institutional holders on record. The largest holder is LINDNER CARL H III with 3,150,068 shares. Other notable holders include LINDNER S CRAIG and Thompson David Lawrence Jr.

Over the last 12 months, insiders have made 44 transactions in AFG stock — 20 buys (valued at RSU Award) and 4 sells (valued at $1.94M). Insider buying has outpaced selling during this period, which may signal confidence in the company's prospects.

AFG Insider Ownership

Top Holder

LINDNER CARL H III

3,150,068 shares

Buys (12 mo)

$0.00 value

Sells (12 mo)

$1.94M value

12-Month Transaction Activity

Buy 45%

Sell 9%

Top Insider Holders

#	Name	Role	Shares Owned	Last Filed	Relative Size
1	Lindner Carl H Iii	Co-CEO	3,150,068	2026-03-02	100%
2	Lindner S Craig	Co-CEO	2,868,715	2026-03-02	91%
3	Thompson David Lawrence Jr	President of Subsidiary	594,948	2026-03-02	19%
4	Lindner Stephen Craig Jr	Director	329,163	2026-03-02	10%
5	Consolino Joseph E	Executive Vice President	214,093	2020-02-27	7%
6	Evans James E	Director	106,581	2024-06-04	3%
7	Peraino Vito C	Senior VP & Executive Counsel	81,050	2023-05-22	3%
8	Berding John B	President	77,616	2026-03-02	2%
9	Ambrecht Kenneth C	Director	60,455	2020-09-03	2%
10	Gillis Michelle A	Senior Vice President	15,382	2026-03-02	0%
11	Hertzman Brian S.	SVP, CFO	13,736	2026-03-02	0%
12	Verity William W	Director	13,119	2025-06-02	0%
13	Drosos Virginia	Director	12,619	2021-06-02	0%
14	Von Lehman John I	Director	12,463	2025-06-02	0%
15	Weiss Mark A	Sr. VP & General Counsel	11,727	2026-03-02	0%
16	Martin Mary Beth	Director	10,194	2025-06-02	0%
17	Jacobs Terry S	Director	7,500	2023-06-13	0%
18	Nwankwo Evans N	Director	6,347	2025-06-02	0%
19	Newport Roger K	Director	3,662	2025-06-02	0%
20	Murray Amy Y	Director	2,651	2025-09-04	0%

Recent Transactions (last 12 months)

Date	Name	Role	Type	Shares	Price	Value
2026-02-26	Lindner Stephen Craig Jr	Director	RSU Award	3,389	-	-
2026-02-26	Weiss Mark A	Sr. VP & General Counsel	RSU Award	3,012	-	-
2026-02-26	Thompson David Lawrence Jr	President of Subsidiary	RSU Award	4,706	-	-
2026-02-27	Hertzman Brian S.	SVP, CFO	Informative Sell	1,663	$133.70	$222.35K
2026-02-26	Hertzman Brian S.	SVP, CFO	RSU Award	3,163	-	-
2026-02-26	Gillis Michelle A	Senior Vice President	RSU Award	3,012	-	-
2026-02-26	Berding John B	President	RSU Award	8,847	-	-
2026-02-26	Lindner Carl H Iii	Co-CEO	RSU Award	11,294	-	-
2026-02-26	Lindner S Craig	Co-CEO	RSU Award	11,294	-	-
2026-02-23	Lindner Stephen Craig Jr	Director	Tax Withholding of RSU	761	$129.85	$98.81K
2026-02-23	Weiss Mark A	Sr. VP & General Counsel	Tax Withholding of RSU	658	$129.85	$85.44K
2026-02-23	Thompson David Lawrence Jr	President of Subsidiary	Tax Withholding of RSU	1,098	$129.85	$142.57K
2026-02-22	Hertzman Brian S.	SVP, CFO	Tax Withholding of RSU	727	$129.85	$94.4K
2026-02-23	Gillis Michelle A	Senior Vice President	Tax Withholding of RSU	730	$129.85	$94.79K
2026-02-23	Berding John B	President	Tax Withholding of RSU	2,050	$129.85	$266.19K
2026-02-23	Lindner Carl H Iii	Co-CEO	Tax Withholding of RSU	3,810	$129.85	$494.72K
2026-02-23	Lindner S Craig	Co-CEO	Tax Withholding of RSU	3,300	$129.85	$428.5K
2025-12-31	Hertzman Brian S.	SVP, CFO	Unknown	-	-	-
2025-12-31	Joseph Gregory G	Director	Unknown	-	-	-
2025-12-31	Berding John B	President	Unknown	-	-	-
2025-12-31	Lindner S Craig	Co-CEO	Unknown	-	-	-
2026-01-28	Lindner Stephen Craig Jr	Director	Gift (Received)	147	-	-
2025-12-29	Gillis Michelle A	Senior Vice President	Gift (Given)	542	-	-
2025-12-18	Lindner Stephen Craig Jr	Director	Gift (Given)	44	-	-
2025-12-18	Thompson David Lawrence Jr	President of Subsidiary	Gift (Given)	828	-	-