Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. NIC NYSE

NYSE • Financial Services • Banks - Regional • US • USD

SharesGrow Score

76/100

5/7 Pass

SharesGrow Intrinsic Value

Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. (NIC) has 20 known insider and institutional holders on record. The largest holder is Smith Oliver Pierce with 445,687 shares. Other notable holders include DANIELS MICHAEL E and MERKATORIS SUSAN L.

Over the last 12 months, insiders have made 98 transactions in NIC stock — 67 buys (valued at $8.94M) and 6 sells (valued at $531.27K). Insider buying has outpaced selling during this period, which may signal confidence in the company's prospects.

NIC Insider Ownership

Top Holder

Smith Oliver Pierce

445,687 shares

Buys (12 mo)

$8.94M value

Sells (12 mo)

$531.27K value

12-Month Transaction Activity

Buy 68%

Sell 6%

Top Insider Holders

#	Name	Role	Shares Owned	Last Filed	Relative Size
1	Smith Oliver Pierce	Director	445,687	2025-05-22	100%
2	Daniels Michael E	Chairman, President & CEO	126,799	2026-02-17	28%
3	Merkatoris Susan L	Director	78,622	2025-05-22	18%
4	Moore Hubert Phillip Jr	CFO	39,015	2026-02-17	9%
5	Hutjens Brad Vincent	EVP - Cco - Nicolet Natl Bank	35,530	2026-02-17	8%
6	Witczak Eric James	EVP & Secretary	34,776	2026-02-17	8%
7	Atwell Robert Bruce	Director	34,054	2026-03-16	8%
8	Mccormick Tracy S	Director	29,797	2026-02-18	7%
9	Lawson Ann Kuchera	Director	27,479	2022-05-19	6%
10	Tobias Paul Davison	Director	23,930	2022-05-19	5%
11	Steppe Michael Joseph	CIO - Nicolet National Bank	19,800	2019-04-11	4%
12	Bohn William M	EVP Wealth Mgmt - Nicolet Bank	17,483	2026-02-17	4%
13	Vogel Michael Joseph	SVP Comm Bank-nicolet Nat Bank	15,344	2020-11-16	3%
14	Davis Lynn Dale	Director	12,304	2025-05-21	3%
15	Lambrecht Marc Thomas	Controller	10,000	2021-06-10	2%
16	Weyers Robert J	Director	9,774	2026-01-21	2%
17	Dykema John Nicholas	Director	9,644	2026-01-21	2%
18	Long Donald J Jr	Director	5,599	2026-01-21	1%
19	Madson Patrick Joseph	SVP-wealth Mgmt-nicoletnatbank	5,032	2023-12-18	1%
20	Rose Randy James	Director	4,708	2020-04-22	1%

Recent Transactions (last 12 months)

Date	Name	Role	Type	Shares	Price	Value
2026-03-12	Atwell Robert Bruce	Director	Informative Sell	100	$150.27	$15.03K
2026-03-05	Atwell Robert Bruce	Director	Informative Sell	116	$152.05	$17.64K
2026-02-18	Atwell Robert Bruce	Director	Option Exercise (Sell)	15,000	$48.85	$732.75K
2026-02-13	Godwin Janet E	Director	RSU Award	3,364	-	-
2026-02-13	Godwin Janet E	Director	Unknown	-	-	-
2026-02-13	Hayek Matthew J	Director	RSU Award	4,063	-	-
2026-02-13	Hayek Matthew J	Director	Unknown	-	-	-
2026-02-13	Mccormick Tracy S	Director	RSU Award	29,797	-	-
2026-02-13	Mccormick Tracy S	Director	Unknown	-	-	-
2026-02-13	Chaney Carl J	Director	RSU Award	767	-	-
2026-02-13	Chaney Carl J	Director	Unknown	-	-	-
2026-02-13	Moore Hubert Phillip Jr	CFO	Tax Withholding of RSU	1,122	$155.19	$174.12K
2026-02-13	Witczak Eric James	EVP & Secretary	Tax Withholding of RSU	1,118	$155.19	$173.5K
2026-02-13	Hutjens Brad Vincent	EVP - Cco - Nicolet Natl Bank	Tax Withholding of RSU	1,090	$155.19	$169.16K
2026-02-13	Daniels Michael E	Chairman, President & CEO	Tax Withholding of RSU	2,624	$155.19	$407.22K
2026-02-13	Bohn William M	EVP Wealth Mgmt - Nicolet Bank	Tax Withholding of RSU	1,080	$155.19	$167.61K
2026-01-20	Hetzel Andrew F Jr	Director	RSU Award	8	$131.43	$1.05K
2025-10-21	Hetzel Andrew F Jr	Director	RSU Award	8	$129.40	$1.04K
2026-01-20	Johnson Brenda L	Director	RSU Award	8	$131.43	$1.05K
2026-01-20	Colon Hector	Director	RSU Award	15	$131.43	$1.97K
2026-01-20	Moore Hubert Phillip Jr	CFO	RSU Award	4,065	$131.43	$534.26K
2026-01-20	Anderson Marcia M	Director	RSU Award	8	$131.43	$1.05K
2026-01-20	Mcclone Dustin James	Director	RSU Award	15	$131.43	$1.97K
2026-01-20	Witczak Eric James	EVP & Secretary	RSU Award	4,065	$131.43	$534.26K
2026-01-20	Hutjens Brad Vincent	EVP - Cco - Nicolet Natl Bank	RSU Award	3,850	$131.43	$506.01K